Loading...
1986 05 08 CC Minutes60508-1 MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BAYTOWN May 81 1986 The City Council of the City of Baytown, Texas, met in regular session on Thursday, May 8, 1986, at 6:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber of the Baytown City Hall with the following attendance: Jimmy Johnson Perry M. Simmons Ron Embry Roy Fuller Rolland J. Pruett Fred T. Philips Fritz Lanham Larry Patterson Randy Strong Eileen P. Hall Absent: Emmett 0. Hutto Councilman Councilman Councilman Councilman Councilman Mayor Pro Tempore City Manager Assistant City Manager City Attorney City Clerk Mayor The meeting was called to order with a quorum present. The invocation was offered by Councilman Pruett, after which the following business was conducted: Consider Minutes for the Regular Meeting Held April 24, 1986 and the Special Meeting Held April 28, 1986 Councilman Embry moved for approval of the minutes for the meeting held on April 24, 1986; Councilman Johnson seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None Councilman Johnson moved for approval of the minutes for the meeting held on April 28, 1986; Councilman Embry seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None Citizen Communications No one requested to speak. 60508-2 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 Consider Plans and Specifications for the Fire Administration Building and Authorize Advertisement for Bids Bill Burge, architect for construction of the fire administration building, was present to review the plans. He stated that the administration building will have 6,400 square feet and based on similar buildings around town should cost about $50 a square foot. The shop building has 41800 square feet, and the architect feels that the cost should be about $40 per square foot. The cover between the two buildings contains 640 square feet at an estimate of $25 per square foot. There will be 42,000 square feet of paving. The estimated cost for the base building is $635,000. There is an alternate bid for parking along Wye Drive because parking in the vicinity of the police building gets heavy due to the municipal court. If the bids come in so that the additional parking can be provided, it will serve the present building, as well as anything that may be constructed across the street in the future. The drawings showed the location of the building which is toward the back of the property along Wye Drive so that the balance of the property can be developed at a future date. At some future date, the police will need the whole building at their present location, and the logical thing at that point would be to construct a municipal court building across the street. For that reason, the fire administration building will be constructed so that it looks like it belongs with the police building. The police building is a brick building with a buff type brick and a heavy stucco band around the roof line, and for the higher element, there is a metal slooping structure that houses the upper part of the municipal court building. There are no flat roofs, nor built-up gavel roofs planned. All the roofs are metal specified to be a Butler MR-24 roof which is a metal roof with a minimum sloop of 1/4 inch per foot. The firm of Les McDonald and Pat Mann, MNM Engineers, are performing the mechanical, electrical and plumbing drawings on the building. The type insulation required for the building has been discussed. The proposal is to have six inches of fiberglass insulation on the roof and double masonry wall on the outside with a one inch expanded foam insulation attached on the inside.of that cavity. Therefore, this should be a well insulated building. The air conditioning is a zoned type which will allow the heating and cooling in parts of the building at the same time. It is designed to take advantage of the heat load in the building with the lights and the people to be a part of the heating of the building. The bail bond building will need to relocate about 70 or 100 feet. 60508-3 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 The shop and the fire administration building are separated by a drive that goes between with a cover over it so that one can get into the building under cover. The structure will be a steel structure so that none of the walls inside the building are load bearing. They could be moved in the future. It is a semi -movable wall system in that it is a Rayco System that has been proposed. The building would have its steel structure and then its masonry envelope and the steel roof. The ceiling would be suspended to 8 foot 8 inches. The ceiling is on a two foot grid so that every two feet a wall can be positioned. The administration recommended approval of the plans and authorization to advertise for bids. In response to inquiry from council, Mr. Burge stated that he is working with Wayne Smith and Associates con- cerning drainage for the site and that the building has been equipped to accomodate the handicapped. Councilman Johnson moved to accept the plans and to authorize advertisement for bids; Councilman Pruett seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None Consider Removal of Planters Along Texas Avenue Mayor Pro Tempore Philips commented that through discussions with several persons this issue could be evenly divided --those that would like to have the planters removed and those that feel they serve a useful purpose. Since the council has not taken a formal stance in this regard, Mayor Pro Tempore Philips opened the matter up for discussion. The city manager was asked to update council with re- gard to traffic counts for that area. A three day count on Texas Avenue, west of Gaillard averaged about 3,200 auto- mobiles. Defee, between Commerce and Pruett averaged 3,570, and Sterling Street, in the same area, averaged 3,000. In considering this, one must consider that both Sterling Street and Defee Street are one-way streets which represent a total of about 6,500 in comparison to the 3,200 figure. Bobby Rountree, Director of Parks and Recreation, showed a slide presentation -to council of the Texas Avenue area taken in 1976 at the time the serpentine street was constructed which slides give an idea of the before and after effect of the planters. The serpentine street was a joint project of the city and downtown businesses. The total cost for construction was $46,500 with the downtown merchants contributing $19,985 and $900 was contributed for purchase of plants. 60508-4 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 Councilman Johnson stated that he too had received several calls with only one person being in favor of the removal of the planters. Jean Fuller, owner of a business in the downtown area, had requested to speak, but stated that she would reserve any comments to a later time. Tracey Wheeler stated that she was not speaking as a Chamber representative, but as a private citizen. She commented that through her association with the Chamber of Commerce, she meets many visitors to the city and many have commented that Texas Avenue is an interesting street and how they enjoyed the greenery. She reminded council that prior to the serpentine street, citizens had to fear striking the curb with the passenger door or being struck by a passing vehicle as one exited their vehicle. Mr. Lanham pointed out that if certain of the planters prove to be a traffic hazard to cross traffic due to the removal of signals, some of the planters can be removed and the greenery can be cut back. The administration had developed the cost for removal which is approximately $8,300. Currently, about $3,000 annually is expended toward maintenance of the Texas Avenue area. Council concurred that no action was necessary on this item. Consider Proposed Ordinance, Amending Chapter 27 of the Code of Ordinances by the Addition of Section 27-34, Commercial Setback Requirements This item will be placed on the next agenda since council will be meeting with the Planning Commission in a work session prior to that meeting. Consider Proposed Ordinance, Awarding Contract for Construction of Fire Station No. 3 Bids were taken on May 1. Six bids were received, and the low bidder was Moore & Moore Contractors for the bid amount of $445#000. The highest bid was $547,000 from Valcon II, Inc. The low bid was in excess of the amount budgeted for construction of Fire Station No. 3; therefore, Jan Lammers, Architect, and Buddy McBride, Fire Chief worked with Moore & Moore to reduce the contract to the budgeted amount. Through their efforts, the contract has been revised to $373,313. The administration recommended approval of the ordinance. 60508-5 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 Councilman Johnson moved for adoption of the ordinance; Councilman Embry seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None ORDINANCE NO. 4443 AN ORDINANCE ACCEPTING THE BID OF MOORE AND MOORE CONTRACTORS, INC. FOR THE CONSTRUCTION OF FIRE STATION NO. 3 AND AUTHORIZING THE PAYMENT BY THE CITY OF BAYTOWN OF THE SUM OF THREE HUNDRED SEVENTY-THREE THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED THIRTEEN AND N0/100 ($373,313.00) DOLLARS. For revisions and bid tabulation, see Attachment "A." Consider Proposed Ordinance, Amending the Animal Control Ordinance to Provide that the Animal Owner is Financially Responsible for his Animal Randy Strong, City Attorney, stated that under the present ordinance, if an animal bites., scratches or claws someone, and the health officer determines that the animal needs to be quarantined, the animal is quarantined at the pound under the supervision,of the animal control division or at a Licensed Doctor of Veterinary Medicine's office of the owner's choice. There is some cost involved. The current ordinance provides that if the animal is running at large when it bites an individual, the owner is respon- sible for the quarantine charges; however, if the animal was not running at large, then the person that was bitten pays the costs for quarantining the animal. Running at large under the ordinance is if the animal is not confined in a fenced area or is not under direct control by a leash or lead, etc. Recently, a citizen was bitten by a dog on a leash and since the animal was on a leash, the citizen that was bitten had to pay the cost of the quarantine. The proposed ordinance provides for the expense of the quarantine to be borne by the owner whether the dog is running at large or not. The theory is that the owner is ultimately respon- sible for his animal. This would not prohibit the owner from going through the civil processes to collect the expenses incurred for having the animal quarantined if the person bitten were trespassing. The other change is to provide that the city can bring suit to collect the costs that the city incurs for quarantine of the animal. Mayor Pro Tempore Philips recognized Becky Brown who stated that she had no idea that the state statute makes the owner responsible for the actions of his animal. She stated her concern is that someone could climb into her backyard and be bitten because the dog would be protecting its territory. 60508-6 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 Mr. Lanham stated that one reason that the administration is recommending the change is that it is very difficult when someone is bitten to make a determination at that point of who should pay. Mrs. Brown said that she understood. Councilman Fuller moved to adopt the ordinance; Council- man Pruett seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None ORDINANCE NO. 4444 AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 5, SECTION 5-5, "QUARANTINE PROCEDURE," REGULATING THE QUARANTINE OF ANIMALS FOLLOWING A POSSIBLE RABIES EXPOSURE, LIABILITY OF THE ANIMAL OWNER FOR THE EXPENSES THEREOF, AND THE RIGHT OF THE CITY TO BRING SUIT TO COLLECT; AND PROVIDING FOR THE PUBLICATION AND EFFECTIVE DATE THEREOF. In response to an inquiry from council, the police chief stated that it is customary for the animal control people to give a warning on the first call regarding animals running at large. Consider Proposed Ordinance, Changing the Name of Lynchburg Road from Market Street to the Railroad Tracks to J.B. LeFevre Road Councilman Simmons had requested that the administration - place an item on the agenda in this regard. The adminis- tration recommended approval of the ordinance. Councilman Simmons moved for adoption of the ordinance. Councilman Johnson seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and -.Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None ORDINANCE NO. 4445 A ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BAYTOWN, TEXAS, CHANGING THE NAME OF LYNCHBURG ROAD TO J.B. LEFEVRE ROAD; AND PROVIDING FOR THE EFFECTIVE DATE HEREOF. 60508-7 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 Discuss Acceptance of Dedication of Unimproved Right of Way, Being an Extension of Wye Drive The city attorney made reference to an engineer's drawing that was posted in the council chamber which depicted the present location of the police and municipal court building and the proposed site of the fire administration building, along with the current location of Wye Drive in relation to those sites. The Baytown Police Association owns a tract of land behind the police station that is land locked with no access to any roadways. Immediately south of that is a parcel of property that belongs to Mr. Leroy Walker, including a small segment that protrudes out to meet Wye Drive. Mr. Walker is sympathetic to the police association. They need access to Wye Drive because they desire to construct a building on their site. Mr. Walker is proposing the dedication of land from the end of the current Wye Drive back to a point along side the association property to the City of Baytown. The problem is that the current policy of the city is that unimproved right of way will not be accepted. Mr. Walker wants to help the police association, but does not want to have to build a street since it is of no benefit to him at this point. Therefore, what he is asking is for the city to accept the unimproved right of way to Wye Drive with the understanding that'the city will allow the police assiciation to utilize the right of way until such time the city is willing to improve the road. Councilman Johnson inquired why Mr. Walker would not consider building the roadway since that would enhance his property, but the city attorney responded that Mr. Walker already has access to Wye Drive. The City of Baytown owns the property on both sides of most of the proposed dedication. Mr. Walker is not willing to give the police association a permanent easement because the property is up for sale and that might impair the sale of the property. The new owner may'not want to allow the use of the property. The main problem is that a building permit cannot be issued to construct the building without access to a public street, and the property is land locked. In response to council, the city attorney pointed out that the tract is about 50 feet wide and about 320 feet long. The city attorney reviewed the ordinance and stated that Chapter 26 of the Code of Ordinance; Section 26-40, speaks in terms'of an improved street, but it does not specifically say that it has to be an improved street, however, it is couched in terms that one would think that. This would be an exception to the standard practice. The ordinance speaks of acceptance after the street construction has been approved by the city engineer which implies that it should be an improved street. 60508-8 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 Council had several questions concerning the proposed dedication and the proposed construction of a building at that location. They were interested in utilities for the building and the availability of fire protection. The fire hydrant is located on North Main. Councilmen Embry and Fuller felt that the association needed to respond to the concerns expressed by council prior to council making a decision. Councilman Fuller moved to table the item so that additional information could be developed, including some input from the parties involved; Councilman Embry seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None Abstained: Councilman Johnson Consider Variance to the Curb and Driveway Requirements for the Fire Station at Fayle and Tenth Streets Mr. Lanham explained that the Code of Ordinances of the City of Baytown provides that the city engineer will prepare driveway standards which standards are attached as part of the ordinance. The curb opening standards, in the case of the fire station at Fayle and Tenth Streets, provide that there could be two, thirty-five foot openings with a twenty foot divide. That was a problem; therefore, the city engineer and chief building inspector approved a deviation from the standard curb to a laid-back curb. That was the way that the contractor was to build the curb, but the foreman on the job was ill the day it was poured, and what was poured is not what was approved. Since that time, various people have suggested that the curb at that location be eliminated completely which would improve access to the station. However, the administration felt what was originally approved would work for the fire station and would not be completely deviating from the present driveway standards. Councilman Pruett moved to allow a variance to the ordinance to exempt fire stations and in this particular case suggested that there be one valley gutter; Councilman Fuller seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None 60508-9 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 Consider Approving Plans for Removal of Medians on North Main Street and Consider Proposed Ordinance, Authorizing Agreement with Harris County for Improvements to North Main The Mayor and others have been working with Commissioner Fonteno for several months on this project. The county has agreed to remove the medians on North Main Street on a cost - sharing basis. The estimated costs to remove the medians is $417,500, and the agreement with Harris County would authorize the City of Baytown to pay up to $208,750. The county has already advertised for bids. The city engineer stated that the total project is from Baker Road to Cedar Bayou Road or a little over 8,000 feet. The proposal is to remove the medians, and the channelized curbs for the left turns. Where the medians now exist, the concrete will be replaced with ten inches of reinforced concrete and below that the subgrade will be stabilized for six inches. Ten inches is what is existing now. When the removal is completed, the contractor will stripe the street for the protected left turn lane. The city is proposing that the county retain the median at North Main and Baker because it protects the signal at that location. The highway department is working with the intersection of Loop 201 at North Main. The plans for that provide for a left turn onto the surface roads. Eventually, when the overpass is constructed at that location, there will be columns with a median around the columns. The medians at North Main and Lynchburg Cedar Bayou Road will remain, but these enhance left turn movement at that location. The project will be funded through the use of bond funds which will almost deplete that fund. The administration requested that council approve the plans and authorize the agreement with Harris County. Councilman Embry moved to approve the plans and to adopt the proposed ordinance authorizing the agreement with Harris County for improvements to North Main. Councilman Pruett seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None 60508-10 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 ORDINANCE NO. 4446 AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE AND THE CITY CLERK TO ATTEST TO AN AGREEMENT WITH HARRIS COUNTY PROVIDING FOR JOINT PARTICIPATION BETWEEN THE CITY AND COUNTY WITH REGARD TO THE IMPROVEMENT OF NORTH MAIN STREET IN BAYTOWN; AND PROVIDING FOR THE EFFECTIVE DATE HEREOF. Consent Agenda Council considered the consent agenda as follows: a. Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-6, will establish a "no parking restriction" on Oakwood Street between Airhart Drive and Beech Street - both sides of the street. Removal of parking along this section of road would provide easier movement of traffic. This restriction has been before the Traffic Commission and meets with their approval. We recommend approval of Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-6. b. Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-7, will remove the "right lane must turn right restriction" on Rollingbrook Drive at North Main. The Traffic Commission has reviewed this request and feels that the improvements to Massey Tompkins east of North Main have removed the necessity for this requirement. We recommend approval of Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-7. c. Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-81 will establish a load/unloading zone on Martin L. King Street at the Bayshore Community Development Office. This zone would be on the west side of Martin Luther King. The zone would be 95 feet north of its intersection with Carver Street for a distance of 50 feet. This restriction is requested to allow for loading and unloading of vans that operate from the Bayshore Community Development office. We recommend approval of Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-8. 60508-11 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 d. Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-9, will award the contract for the Community Development: Ash, Willow, and Huggins Street and Drainage Improve- ments. Bids were opened on April 22, 1986, for the 1984-85 Community Development Project: Street and Drainage Improvements to Ash, Willow and Huggins Streets. Angel Brothers Enterprises, Inc. was the low bidder. Seven bids were received. Angel Brothers submitted a bid of $816,119.40. This represents a base bid of $766,500.90 and an alternate bid of $49,618.50 for sidewalks on Huggins if funding permits. Ash and Willow Streets will be funded by the 1984 Community Development Program which has $450,000 available. Huggins Street will be funded by the 1985 Community Development Program which has $400,000 available. We recommend the low bidder, Angel Brothers Enterprises, Inc. be awarded this contract. e. Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-10, will authorize final payment to Eiserer Construction for Massey - Tompkins paving at North Main. Eiserer Construction Company completed their work on April 16, 1986. A final inspection was made jointly by representatives of the city's Engineering Department and Busch - Hutchison and Associates, Inc. The original contract amount was $236,684. There were two change orders of $6,940 and $7,145, making a total contract amount of $250,769. The final cost of all work completed totals $217,693.13, making an underrun on the project of $33,075.87. Funds are available in the 1981 Street Bond Program. We recommend a final payment of $35,405.21 be made to Eiserer Construction Company. f. Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-11, will award the annual fiberglass manholes contract. Bids were „sent to seven vendors and five bids were received. Municipal Pipe & Fabricating submitted the low bid of $10,334.30. We recommend the low bidder, Municipal Pipe & Fabricating be awarded this contract. g. Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-12, will award the bid for water pumps. Bids were mailed to sixteen vendors and four proposals were received. The low bidder, Acme Pumps & Wellpoints did not sign their invitation to bid therefore we cannot accept their proposal. Their bid was in the amount of $2,460. The second low bidder was Kinco, Inc. who submitted a bid of $2,758.71. We recommend the low bidder meeting specification, Kinco, Inc. be awarded this contract. 60508-12 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8., 1986 h. Proposed Ordinance No: 60508-13, will award the bid for PVC pipe and fittings. Bids were mailed to ten vendors and seven bids were received along with one no bid. The low bidders meeting specifi- cations are as follows: 1. Item #1 - Aqua Utility 2. Item 2 & 3 - Municipal Pipe 3. Item 4 - Golden Triangle The total bid amount is $73,661.77. We recommend the low bidders, Aqua Utility (item one), Municipal Pipe (items 2 and 3), and Golden Triangle (item 4) be awarded this contract. i. Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-14, will award the bid for traffic signal equipment. Bids were mailed to seven vendors. Three proposals were received. The low bidders meeting specifications are as follows: 1. Item #1 - Sanspar 2. Item #2 - Pfeiffer Electric The total bid amount was $36,641.20. We recommend the low bidders, Sanspar (item one) and Pfeiffer Electric (item two), be awarded this contract. j. Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-15, will award the bid for the repair parts for track excavator. Bids were mailed to four vendors and only one proposal was received. The lone bidder, Brookside Equipment Sales, Inc. offers the city a bid of $4,964.74 for a swing gearbox and parts to repair the hydraulic cylinders on our 1974 John Deere 690B Track Excavator, or an alternate of $5,402.42 for a swing gearbox and two new complete hydraulic cylinders. We recommend that council accept the solicited alternate bid of $5,402.42 from Brookside Equipment for the swing gearbox and two new hydraulic cylinders. The difference between the two options is $437.60, but to assemble the hydraulic cylinder parts in item 2 of this bid would cost us an estimated $775. We feel that the alternate would save money. Councilman Johnson moved for adoption of the Consent Agenda Item Nos. a'through j: Councilman Embry seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None 60508-13 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 ORDINANCE NO. 4447 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BAYTOWN, TEXAS, DESIGNATING A PORTION OF OAKWOOD STREET AS A NO PARKING ZONE; REPEALING CONFLICTING ORDINANCES HEREWITH; CONTAINING A SAVINGS CLAUSE; PRESCRIBING A MAXIMUM PENALTY OF TWO HUNDRED AND NO/100 ($200.00) DOLLARS FOR EACH VIOLATION THEREOF; AND PROVIDING FOR THE PUBLICATION AND EFFECTIVE DATE HEREOF. (Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-6) ORDINANCE NO. 4448 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BAYTOWN, TEXAS, REPEALING THE DESIGNATION OF THE INTERSECTION OF ROLLINGBROOK DRIVE AT NORTH MAIN STREET AS A NO RIGHT TURN ON RED INTERSECTION; REPEALING CONFLICTING ORDINANCES; CONTAINING A SAVINGS CLAUSE; AND PROVIDING FOR THE EFFECTIVE DATE HEREOF. (Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-7) ORDINANCE NO. 4449 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF BAYTOWN, TEXAS, DESIGNATING A PORTION OF MARTIN LUTHER KING STREET AS A NO LOADING ZONE; REPEALING CONFLICTING ORDINANCES HEREWITH; CONTAINING A SAVINGS CLAUSE; PRESCRIBING A MAXIMUM PENALTY OF TWO HUNDRED AND N0/100 ($200.00) DOLLARS FOR EACH VIOLATION THEREOF; AND PROVIDING FOR THE PUBLICATION AND EFFECTIVE DATE HEREOF. (Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-8) ORDINANCE NO. 4450 AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE MAYOR AND CITY CLERK TO EXECUTE AND ATTEST TO A CONTRACT WITH ANGEL BROTHERS ENTERPRISES, INC. FOR THE 1984-85 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PROJECT; MAKING OTHER PROVISIONS RELATED THERETO; AND PROVIDING FOR THE EFFECTIVE DATE HEREOF. (Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-9) ORDINANCE NO. 4451 AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING FINAL PAYMENT TO EISERER CONSTRUCTION COMPANY FOR MASSEY-TOMPKINS PAVING AT NORTH MAIN; AND PROVIDING FOR THE EFFECTIVE DATE HEREOF. (Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-10) ORDINANCE NO. 4452 AN ORDINANCE ACCEPTING THE BID OF MUNICIPAL PIPE AND FABRICATING FOR THE ANNUAL FIBERGLASS MANHOLES CONTRACT AND AUTHORIZING THE PAYMENT BY THE CITY OF BAYTOWN OF THE SUM OF TEN THOUSAND THREE HUNDRED THIRTY-FOUR AND 30/100 ($10,334.30) DOLLARS. (Proposed Ordinance NO. 60508-11) 60508-14 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 ORDINANCE NO. 4453 AN ORDINANCE ACCEPTING THE BID OF KINCO, INC. FOR THE PURCHASE OF WATER PUMPS AND AUTHORIZING THE PAYMENT BY THE CITY OF BAYTOWN OF THE SUM OF TWO THOUSAND SEVEN HUNDRED FIFTY-EIGHT AND 71/100 ($2,758.71) DOLLARS. (Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-12) ORDINANCE NO. 4454 AN ORDINANCE ACCEPTING THE BID OF AQUA UTILITY, MUNICIPAL PIPE AND GOLDEN TRIANGLE FOR THE ANNUAL PVC PIPE AND FITTINGS CONTRACT AND AUTHORIZING THE PAYMENT BY THE CITY OF BAYTOWN OF THE SUM OF SEVENTY-THREE THOUSAND SIX HUNDRED SIXTY-ONE AND 77/100 ($73,661.77) DOLLARS. (Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-13) ORDINANCE NO. 4455 AN ORDINANCE ACCEPTING THE BID OF SANSPAR AND PFEIFFER ELECTRIC FOR THE ANNUAL INSTALLATION OF TRAFFIC SIGNAL EQUIPMENT CONTRACT AND AUTHORIZING THE PAYMENT BY THE CITY OF BAYTOWN OF THE SUM OF THIRTY-SIX THOUSAND SIX HUNDRED FORTY-ONE AND 20/100 ($36,641.20) DOLLARS. (Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-14) ORDINANCE NO. 4456 AN ORDINANCE ACCEPTING THE BID OF BROOKSIDE EQUIPMENT SALE, INC. FOR THE REPAIR OF PARTS FOR A TRACK EXCAVATOR AND AUTHORIZING THE PAYMENT BY THE CITY OF BAYTOWN OF THE SUM OF FIVE THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED TWO AND 42/100 ($5,402.42) DOLLARS. (Proposed Ordinance No. 60508-15) For bid tabulations, see Attachments "B" through "G." Consider Appointments to the Planning Commission These appointments will be made at a future meeting. Consider Appointments to the Auto Wrecker Committee Councilman Johnson moved to reappoint Norman Ponder to another two-year term as a member of the Auto Wrecker Committee and to appoint Jesse Shead to replace Joe Wheat. Councilman Simmons seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None 60508--15 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 Councilman Johnson requested that Mr. Wheat be called after the council meeting to be notified so that he would know of the appointment in advance of the story appearing in the Baytown Sun. He also asked that a letter be forwarded to Mr. Wheat expressing council's appreciation for his three years of service. Consider Appointments to the Baytown Housing Finance Corporation These appointments will be made at a future council meeting. Consider Appointment to the Urban Rehabilitation Standards Review Board Councilman Pruett moved to appoint the Reverend Dwayne McAlister to serve on the Urban Rehabilitation Standards Review Board; Councilman Embry seconded the motion. The vote follows: Ayes: Council members Johnson, Simmons, Embry, Fuller and Pruett Mayor Pro Tempore Philips Nays: None Citv Manaaer's Report Bond Ratings - In connection with the bond sale that is scheduled for Tuesday, May 18, 1986 at 5:00 p.m., the rating firms have notified the City of Baytown of their prospective ratings. A delegation from Baytown met with the two rating firms concerning the bond sale on Wednesday. Mayor Hutto, Council- man Fuller, the Finance Director, Ken Mitchell and the City Manager, Fritz Lanham represented the city, along with representatives of Underwood, Neuhaus. They met with Standards and Poors for two hours in the morning, and this firm has continued the AA rating. This firm was very com- plimentary of the presentation and very pleased with the information presented. The delegation met with Moody's analysts for three hours, and there have been numerous telephone conversations since that time to furnish further information. They were extremely thorough in their evaluation'of Baytown. They are concerned about the economic conditions of the area and the future of this area. Baytown's representatives never denied that there are problems with the economy and that the growth had leveled off and there had been a high unemployment rate. The group had hoped that there would be enough positive elements in 60508-16 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 the economy and the city that could be pointed out that would offset some of the negatives. However, in the analysts judgement, this was not the case because Moody's downgraded the city from AA to A-1 rating which was what the city had until 3 or 4 years ago when the rating was upgraded. The analysts were concerned about some of the actions that were forced due to the economic conditions such as the transfer of funds from one account to another; reduction in contingencies and other balances; failing to reach all revenue projections; the necessity to reduce capital. Mr. Lanham stated that he felt that once the economic conditions change that the City of Baytown can win back its AA rating. A reduction in rating from AA to A-1 could result in a cost to the city of 1/8 of one percent. If that is correct, it could cost between $50,000 and $60,000 over the life of the bonds. In response to an inquiry from council, Mr. Lanham stated that the rating firms like to feel that Baytown's city government will do whatever is necessary to keep the city's finances in good order. Therefore, the delegation used the example that taxes were increased after Alicia in order to deal with a difficult situation and that user charges have been raised from time to time. They like to see good year-end balances. They like to see sizeable contingencies so that if there is a real problem there is something to fall back on. Community Development Entitlement for 1986 - HUD has notified the administration that the Community Development Entitlement for 1986 will be $550,000 which is a very substantial reduction from the 1985 entitlement of $786,000. Police Memorial Service - Each council member received an invitation to attend the Police Memorial Service to be held on Thursday, May 15 at 7:30 a.m. in front of the police building. Ambulance Service - There has been some confusion with regard to providing ambulance service to some of the areas north of Interstate 10, particularly the Meadow Lake Subdivision and East Point. The City of Baytown serves those areas with fire service, and the staff requested council authorization to run ambulance service calls to that area. This area is outside the city limits, but it is an area already being served with fire services. There would be a gap if the city did not provide ambulance service to this area. That area is in the 9-1-1 System, and there would be no additional costs involved under the contract. The contract does provide a.clause'which stipulates other designated areas may be served. Council had no objections. t Larry Patterson, Assistant City Manager, did indicate that there may be other areas that may need to be included and those will be brought to council's attention. 60508-17 Minutes of the Regular Meeting - May 8, 1986 Sliplining - With regard to sliplining contracts, there are two sliplining contractors working. One completed the installation of 415 linear feet of pipe and 26 service connections between Pine and Cherry Streets. The other contractor, which contract is being funded with Community Development money on Huggins Street, has installed 275 feet of pipe, and they expect to install 1,350 feet today. There are no service connections on this job. East Sewer District - The contractor has placed the Woodlawn Lift Station in service, and it is operating satisfactorily. There are a few punch list items that remain. Councilman Johnson asked that the city mow the property along Woodlawn that is at the curve. Massey Tompkins Elevated Water Storage Tank - The contractor has completed clearing of the site, and the pile driving equipment is on site and waiting for test piles in order to move ahead. Recess into Executive Session to Discuss Pending and Contemplated Litigation: a. Brownwood Mayor Pro Tempore Philips recessed the open meeting into executive session to discuss pending and contemplated litigation pertaining to Brownwood. When the open meeting reconvened, he announced that there was no action as a result of the executive session. Adjourn There being no further business to be transacted, the meeting was adjourned. Eileen P. Hall, City Clerk Attachment "A" THE LAMMERS PARTNERSHIP ARCHITECTS & PLANNERS A.I.A. OAAWEA SOO '700 E. TEXAS AVE. SAYTOWIV, TEXAS 770E0 9 712 3 4E7-1737 May 8. 1986 Fritz .Lanham, City Manager City of Baytown P.O. Box 424 Baytown. Texas 77522 Re: Fire Station #3 Bid Dear Mr. Lanham: We have been diligently working with Moore 8 Moore Contractors, the low bidder, on Fire Station #3. In an effort to reduce the bid price to better respond to the City's budget we have established a list of items offered as credit as follows: 1. Alt. #2 - Delete skylights $ 2. Alt. #3 - Delete skylights at bay doors 3. Revise structure to include columns at midspan 4. Revise exit lights S. Pour grade beams monolithicly with floor 6. Revise hardware allowance to $3,100 from $8.000 7. Revise graphics 8. Revise rear bay doors to steel with vision panels 9. Revise front doors to double strength glass front laxan 10. Delete wing walls at engine bays 11. Change casework lockers to metal 12. Delete two (2) storage rooms at engine bays 3,100 9.100 4.267 720 3,543 4,800 2.370 9,432 2.200 600 1.270 1,740 Fritz Lanham. City Manager City of Baytown Re: Fire Station #3 Page 2 13. Revise existing cyclone fence material 14. Revise fire poles to job built 800 15. Revise brick from modular to king size 11,697 97 16. Revise bollards 3,800 17. Delete ceramic the in lieu of vinyl wall covering1.414 1,160 at restrooms 18. 19. Delete Delete interior glass at 2nd floor in lieu window blinds of drywall 4 474 20. Revise carpet allowance 1,300 21. Revise bronze and anodized doors at engine bays 1.400 3,000 partitions and revise exterior glass at 2nd floor Total Credit $ 72.187 Base Bid 445,500 CONTJACT PRICE $373,313 It is our recommendation that ore 8 oore Contractors be awarded the contract for construction bas doon t e revised bid price of $ Yours very truly, Jan Lammers. A.I.A. Partner JLL:j1 TABULATION OF BIDDERS - FIRE STATION #3 May 1, 1986 N BID TABULATION Valcon II, Inc. BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days Chatham Construction Co. BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days Moore 8 Moore Contractors BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days Holley Brothers Enterprises BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days Stan Holzaepfel BASE BID Lynn B. Watkins Const. Live Oak Construction Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days $547,000 7,000 2,450 14,400 2,000 180 $457,500 6,618 3,316 16,099 75 180 $445,500 6,000 -. 3,100 12,100 75 150 $469,913 8,000 2,500 18,000 100 180 $545,000 6.320 6.225 16,649 75 180 $477.900 5,725 4,600 18,500 100 165 Bid Unacceptable TABULATION OF BIDDERS - FIRE STATION #3 May 1, 1986 BID TABULATION Valcon II, Inc. BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days Chatham Construction Co. BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days Moore 8 Moore Contractors BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days Holley Brothers Enterprises BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days Stan Holzaepfel Lynn B. Watkins Const. Live Oak Construction BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days BASE BID Alt. #1 Alt. #2 Alt. #3 Alt. #4 Calendar Days $547.000 7,000 2,450 14,400 2.000 180 $457.500 6,618 3,316 16,099 75 180 $445,500 6,000 3,100 12,100 75 150 $469,913 8.000 2,500 18,000 100 180 $545.000 6,320 6,225 16,649 75 180 $477,900 5.725 4,600 18,500 100 165 Bid Unacceptable Attachment "B" COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PROJECT: STREET AND DRAINAGE IMPROVEMENTS TO ASH, WILLOW, AND HUGGINS STREETS BID RESULTS April 22, 1986 Job No. 8512-23 Angel Brothers Enterprises, Inc. Brown & Root USA, Inc. Skrla, Inc. Hubco, Inc. Conrad -Walsh, Inc. Beyer-Schindewolf Construction, Inc. Baytown Construction Company, Inc. Beach Construction Company Bill McDonald Construction, Inc. C. F. Construction, Inc. H. B. Hamilton Construction, Inc. Mason Construction Mischer Paving and Utility Company Teal Contracting Company World -Wide Utility Constructors, Inc. * Base bid, alternate bid, total bid $766,500.90 + $49,618.50 = $816,119.40 $845,380.40 + $51,570.00 = $896,950.40 $854,802.00 + $65,710.00 = $920,512.00 $880,000.00 + $71,610.00 = $951,610.00 $958,769.50 + $36,695.00 = $995,464.50 $999,542.25 + $56,135.00 = $1,055,677.25 $1,050,420.00 + $59,675.00 = $1,110,095.00 Attachment "C" TITLE: ANNUAL FIBERGLASS NAN110LES 810 NUNBER: 8603-57 DATE: /-22-86 2:00 P.N. 1ITEN1 QTY ;UNIT ;DESCRIPTION CITY OF BAYTO1Nl 010 TABULATION j4MULM 1N1AN U , ;UTILITT SUPPLY , 1RONAN COMPANY ;MARQUE CORP. 1 LOT !FIBERGLASS NAMES ; 1 11,837.001 46 ; 11,870.18! ; rw 6[-uwll 12,189.081 ' A1. ►1[ ; 13,617 s s s s s s s s s ! ! ! DELIVERY: 15 DAYS AR0! !AS REQUIRED 1STOCK-7 DAYS AR0 110 DAYS ARO ' s 1 ! WARRANTY: 15 YEARS 1 18Y MANUFACTURER 1S YEARS !1 YEAR s 1 , s 1 ! 1 SPECIAL CONDITIONS:IPRICES Is FIRN 1 FOR ONE 1 1 ! ! ! 1YEAR1. , 1 1 !BIDS NAILED TO I VENDORS.! 1 1 ! ! 1 1 1 ! , ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 1 N CITY OF BAYTOWN BID TABULATION PAGE 2 TITLE: ANNUAL FIBERGLASS NANNOLES BID NUNBER: 8603-57 DATE: 4-22-86 2:00 P.N. 1 1 1 1 ;nu11RIr11L r:F't i FAO.; 1 , , ;ITEN= QTY ;UNIT ;DESCRIPTION 1 1 ' ;UNIT PRICEIEXT. PRICEIUNIT r PRICEIEXT. PRICEIUNIT PRICEIEXT. PRICEIUNIT PRICEIEXT. 1 PRICE; I ; 1 ; LOT ;FIBERGLASS NANNOLES ; ; 10,334.301 _ s s DELIVERY: : l ;STOCK-10 DAYS AID : s VARRANTY: 115 YEARS i i i s SPECIAL CONDITIONS:= I 1 I 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 r 1 1 1 1 t t 1 1 1 1 I 1 t 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 t 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I t 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 i 1 1 1 1 1 i t 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Attachment "D" CITY OF BAYTOWN BID TABULATION TITLE: WATER WELLS 810 NUMBER: 8603-53 DATE: 4-16-86 2:00 P.M. :WACKER CORPORATION :KINCO, INC. ;ACME PUMPS :BAYTEX RENTAL ; :ITEM; QTY :UNIT :DESCRIPTION :UNIT PRICEEXT. PRICE;UNIT PRICE; ' ;EXT. PRICE.11111T PRI('F!FYT_ actrcruulr ontrcrcvr eerrr. ,+ ■n,cn rvnr, ruc i I,u),1.lu; 3,159.30: 919.511 ISPECIFICATIONS r , MODEL: :WACKER/PT3A :WACKER/PT3A I I ; TOTAL: : : 3,159.30: ; I I DELIVERY::14 DAYS : :30 DAYS : (ALTERNATE #1 , : MODEL: : : :ALTERNATE 12 ' : I MODEL: , SPECIAL CONDITIONS:: : , , : :BIDS MAILED TO 16 VENDORS. : r r , , It , 2,758.71: 820.001 2,460.00; 1,265.8311 3,7971111), I I . :SYKES/3MT-8 :WACKER/PT3A , 2,158.71: : '2,460.00: : 3,797.49: r r r r r . :30 DAYS : :7-14 DAYS :MULTI -QUIP QP-301-A ; : 1,088.831 3,266.49: ' :STOW T350 r , : 1,203.83: 3,611.49: ;'DOES NOT MEET : SPECIFICATIONS, DID : NOT SIGN THE 810 PROPOSAL.: ; , Attachment "E" CITY OF BAYTOWN 610 TABULATION TITLE: ANNUAL PVC PIPE AND FITTINGS CONTRACT 810 NUNBER: 8603-54 DATE: 4-29-86 2:00 P.N. 1 1 IITENI 1 1 TRIANGLE ;AQUA QTY ;UNIT ;DESCRIPTION 'UTILITY UTILITY 'UTILITY SUPPLY 'JANCO PIPE , '--'—' (UNIT I. I LOT I LOT IYATER SERVICE PRICE'EXT. PRICE'UNIT 1 PR CE' , XT. PRIC E'UNIT PRICE'EXT. PRICE' NIT PR ' , XT. 2. I LOT I I LOT !SEVER SERVICE , 1 51646.231 20.123.041 I 4.998.421 I 5.840.611 I PRICE; 5,790.08; 3. I i 4. I LOT I LOT I LOT IC-900.81 PVC HATER PIPE ' 1 LOT , 50,112.40, 120,992.81I ! 120,695.48: 50,001.20! 1 22,251./5I I 1PVC PIPE GLUE I CLEANER I I_ 5_S0; I 630.00' 150,798.80� 155,072.00 1 ! ! I 1 1 720.00, I 840.00: ' ' I ! I 1 TOTAL: ! I ! 76,414.171, 1 1 1 ; ' I I 76,622.431 ! 78,054.89' I I 1 1 , 1 , , 1 I 183.953.53; I I ! DELIVERY:IAS I SUPPLY POINT:ICHEEK, REQUIRED 13 DAYS ARO' TX I � I , I IAS REQUIRED I2-3 DAYS ARO 1 I I I ! VARRANTY:IPER I NANUFACTURER I 16825 VALLISVILLE !HOUSTON ' 1 !PER NANUFACTURER I ; I I I I SPECIAL CONDITIONS:' ' (PRICES F1RN—I YEAR 'PRICES FIRN—I YEAR ' 1 ; !8105 NAILED TO 10 VENDORS. 1 I 1 s I I I 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 CITY OF BAYTOWN 810 TABULATION PAGE 2 TITLE: ANNUAL PVC PIPE AND FITTINGS CONTRACT BID NUMBER: 8603-54 DATE: 4-29-86 2100 P.M. ;ITEM= of 1RONAN QTY ;UNIT ;DESCRIPTION 1 CONPANY ;ROYAL PLG. SUPPLY MUNICIPAL PIPE 1 I. ;LOT ;UNIT PRICE'EXT. PRICE'UNIT PRICE ;LOT ;WATER SERVICE , , Q 6,2/6.06, XT. P1111111,111,1111111T PRICE! . 'UNIT PRlCE'EXT. , PRIM, 1 1. ; LOT ; LOT ;SEWER SERVICE ' i 1 22.125.701 7,566.201 ; 6,101.1.1 ' i 3. i LOT 1 lOT 1C-900-81 PVC WATER PIPE i 1 SS,2 25,673.401 1, LMA, , ' 1 4. 1 LOT 1 LOT 1PVC PIPE GLUE 1 CLEANER 1 870.001 66,.001 ! 18.5 0.80' 1 1 1 1 1 78080.001, .001 1 613.501 TOTAL: 1 84,459.761 1100,110.661 11 1 14,846.10'1 1 1 1 1 DELIVERY:13 DAYS ARO' I I , 1 ' 1 1 17-1/ GAYS ARO 13 DAYS ARO1 1 ' 1 1 1 1 SUPPLY POINT:,1 O 1 1NOUSTON ' ' 1 WARRANTY:' 1 , ,NOUSTON PER MANUFACTURER ' 1 1 1 SPECIAL CONDITIONS:1 1 1 1 1 I 1 1 1 1 1 I 1 I o O a N m 00 O a a a �► -- -- ►- -_ -- _► -_ _� � y Y Y -� �-1 Y Y Y of -- _- _= I - � _. A N N � _ �- -• zoz Qqrn Yrc i c^+Qcocoozoz2a2m 1ZA A S •p S r� S� S H C r C r C� S i r A—•••1 Y Y pY 0OY y YO.•.1N �/=-•1�! � p •'- O r z r a"" "" O In A= r O f�1 70 O f�f O A 70 1f N 1f O O moo.-.�cn � C3 c Y en N r O r N S I'm, S Z Y Z Z Ap � �N pp Y= Y ►d _y Z � O O �1 O •-1 C p m r S Z if�1 Z Z s AN r � cn i qLn m A N V. W W V m N -• v+ m o .o N ar ar aNco cm I� YOi 7�0 r Y V m r V� N � N __ -- � 1'•1 V• V W YR A O O W 1 a - • M N O ^ O N ' A O O O O � O O tVJf O O CF., CD cm O A O • ' ' • O O p O O e 0 O -- _► -- _- _► » _ O O �� O O O O O O O O O T an o N - -i V m a m fV /V �O Pen O O O O O O O O O 1A�1 O N 6A W N ♦O N N N V1 y� y� N N W �"� A a LA aA O •p O N m N V a a ' •� O• O O � � l"f N O O O O� N m •O O V� �/ •p N N cl O � N V � V V O� �y ••'1 N Y W i m O O O � y� W _ •_ - •O m � � � N N N V� N O O O O O O N N m O � O � C s ?o _m O O O Y ct {" h w iflD ct 11 CITY OF BAYTOWN 810 TABULATION TITLE: REPAIR PARTS FOR TRACK EXCAVATOR 810 NUMBER: 8603-59 DATE: 1-11-06 2:00 P.M. Attachment "G" ! 1 ! 1 IBROOKSIDE EQUIPMENT 11TENI QTY (UNIT ;DESCRIPTION ► ' ' ' I. EA.�COMPLETE SWING GEARBOX 1UNIT PRICE'EXT. PRICE'UNIT PRICE'EXT. PRICE'UNIT PRICE' XT. PRICE'UM T PRICE'EXT. PRICE! I ; ; ; 2,822.601 ; 1 - 1 2. 1 1 1 i !PARTS FOR 2 HYDRAULIC 1 1 1 1 1 !CYLINDERS 1 a. 1 2 1 EA.ICYLINDER REPAIR KITS 1 61.871 123.741 1 b. 1 1 1 EA.IROD GUIDES ! .85I 1.701 I e. I 2 1 EA.ISNAP RINGS I 5./01 10.801, d. ! / 1 EA.IBRAKE SEAL RINGS ! 8.171 32.68,1 1 I I e. ! 2 ! EA.IPISTONS I 02.19' 164.381 2 ! EA.IPISTONS I 56.391 132.781 1 9. 1 2 1 EA.ICYLINDER BARRELS ! 839.031 1,676.06: SUB -TOTAL ITEM f2 I 1 2,142.141 1 i i 13. ! 2 I EA.IALTERNATE: NEW HYDRAULIC ! 1,289.911 2,579.821 1 1 1 ! 1 ! CYLINDERS 1 1 ! ! ! 1 TOTAL: ! I 7,5/4.56' ! 1 1 ! DELIVERY: 110 DAYS ! ! ! ! 1 1 1 ! ! ! ! 1 !BIDS MAILED TO A VENDORS.1 1 ! ! 1 1 ! ! ! ! 1 ! ! 1 ! 1 ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 1 ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! 1 1 1 ! ! ! ! ! 1 1 1 !