Ordinance No. 1,585ORDINANCE NO.1585
AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITYOF BAYTOWN,AUTHORIZING
THE MAYOR TO EXECUTE AND THE CITY CLERK TO ATTEST TOAN INDUSTRIAL
DISTRICT CONTRACT BETWEEN ASHLAND OIL &REFINING COMPANY ANDTHE CITY
QF BAYTOWN,TEXAS,AND PROVIDING FOR THEEFFECTIVE DATE HEREOF.
WHEREAS,the Municipal Annexation Act,Article 970a,Revised Civil Statutes
of Texas,provides for the creation ofindustrial districts within the extrater
ritorial jurisdiction of cities;and
WHEREAS,pursuant to such Municipal Annexation Act and in the interest of
further cooperation with industry and the economic enhancement of Baytown,the
City Council of the City of Baytown enacted Ordinance No.886,dated the 19th
day of September,1967,designating a part of its extraterritorial jurisdiction
as an industrial district known as Baytown Industrial District No.1;and
WHEREAS,a portion of Ashland Oil &Refining Company's Baytown Plant is
located within Baytown Industrial District No.1;and
WHEREAS,the City Council of the City of Baytown and Ashland Oil &Refining
Companydesire to enter into a new industrial district contract;NOW THEREFORE,
BE U ORDAINED BY THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITYOF BAYTOWN,TEXAS:
Section 1:ThattheCity Council of the City of Baytown authorizes the
Mayor to execute and the City Clerk to attest to an industrial district contract
between.Ashland Oil &Refining Company and the City of Baytown,Texas.A copy
of said contract is attached hereto,marked Exhibit "A,"and made a part hereof
forall intents and purposes.
Section 2:Effective Date:This ordinance shall take effect immediately
from and after its passage by the City Council of the City of Baytown.
INTRODUCED,READ andPASSED by the affirmative vote of the City Council
of the City ofBaytown,this25th dayof April ,1974.
v.—(_^"PLj\A-*A—0
ALLEN CANNON,Mayor Pro Tem
ATTEST:
EDNA OLIVER,CityClerk
APPROVED:
'1.1 -f -
City Attorney
NEEL RICHARDSON,City Attorney
-2-
EXKIB IT "A"
INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT AGREEMENT BETWEEN
ASHLAND CHEMICAL COMPANY
DIVISION OF ASHLAND OIL,INC.
AND
THE CITY OF .BAYTOWN,TEXAS
This Agreement is made and entered into between the City of Baytown,
Texas,a municipal corporation in Harris County,Texas,hereinafter also referred
to as "Baytown"and "City,"and Ashland Chemical Company,Division of Ashland Oil,
Inc.,a Kentucky corporaton with a permit to engage in business in the State
of Texas,hereinafter referred to as "Company"and "Ashland":
WHEREAS,Baytown has a history of cooperating with industries located
within and near its city limits;and
WHEREAS,the City Council of the City of Baytown is of the considered
opinion that such cooperation results in economic growth and stability for
Baytown and its adjacent areas;and
WHEREAS,the Texas Legislature in 1963 adopted the "Municipal Annexation
Act,"Article 970a,Revised Civil Statutes of Texas,which provides for the
creation of Industrial Districts within the extraterritorial jurisdiction of
cities;and
WHEREAS,pursuant to such Municipal Annexation Act and in the interest
of further cooperation with industry and the economic enhancement of Baytown,
the City of Baytown enacted Ordinance No.886,dated the 19th day ofSeptember,
1967,designating a part of its extraterritorial jurisdiction as an Industrial
District known as Baytown Industrial District No.1;and
WHEREAS,the City Council desires that portion of Ash!and's Baytown
Plant and facilities described in Appendix A be included in the Baytown Industrial
District No.1 and further desires to enter into this contractual agreement
withAshland for this purpose;and
WHEREAS,Ashland's Baytown Plant includes both real and personal property
In its refining and chemical manufacturing and research facilities,including
any office facilities used 1n direct support of these operations and either
situated contiguous thereto or separated by public roads;NOW THEREFORE,
In consideration of the promises and of the mutual covenants and agreements
herein contained,it is agreed by and between the Company and the City of Baytown
as follows:
1.The City of Baytown hereby agrees that all of the land and improvements
thereon owned,used,occupied,leased,rented or possessed by the Company within
the area designated as Baytown Industrial District No.1 by Ordinance No.886
and amendments thereto which Industrial District is more particularly described
in Appendix A tothis Agreement and made a part hereof shall continue its extrater
ritorial status as an Industrial District and shall not be annexed by the City
of Baytown nor shall the City attempt to annex,or in any way cause or permit
to be annexed any of such property during the termof this Agreement.The
City further agrees,promises and guarantees that during the termof this Agreement
the City of Baytown shall not apply or purport to apply any ordinance,rule
or regulation to such property except as relating to noise,vibration,and
pollution performance standards as hereinafter provided.Specifically,but
without limitation,the City agrees,promises and guarantees that it will not
extend to said property any ordinance,rules or regulation (a)governing plats
and the subdivision of land;(b)prescribing any zoning,building,electrical,
plumbing or inspection code or codes;and (c)attempting to exercise in any
manner whatsoever control over the conduct of the Company's business thereon.
The City further agrees that during the term of this Agreement,it will not
levy or purport to levy ad valorem taxes against any real or personal property
owned,used,occupied,leased,rented,or possessed by the Company within the
property boundaries described in said Appendix A.
2.It is further agreed that during the term of this Agreement the
City of Baytown shall not be required to furnish municipal services to the
Company's Baytown Plant,which are ordinarily and customarily supplied by the
City to property owners within its boundaries,except as provided by mutual
agreement.Specifically,but without limitation,it is agreed that the City
of Baytown shall not be required to furnish:(1)sewer or water service,(2)
police protection,(3)fire protection,(4)road orstreetrepairs,and (5)
garbage pickup service.
-2-
3.The Company andthe City recognize that in the past the Company
has paid a share of the needed revenue for operating the City and providing
services for its residents.It is.further recognized that during the next
succeeding seven years the City of Baytown will experience populationgrowth
as a result of industrial expansion which will necessitate increased revenue
to provide expanded service and facilities.In view of this increased need
for revenue,the Company agrees to pay the City an Industrial District payment
on or before January 31 of each year during the term of this agreement an amount
to be calculated on the basis of the following formula,except for calendar
years 1974 and 1975 as hereinafter provided in Paragraph 4:
The Company's Industrial District value,as defined below,x 0.06 x the
property tax rate per $100of assessed valuation adopted by the City
Council forthe City of Baytown for financing the fiscal year in which
such January 31 due date falls.
In applying the above formula,the factor referred to as the "Company's
Industrial District Value"shallbe defined as:
(A)The fair market value of the Company's Baytown Plant within the
City's jurisdiction as of January 1 of the calendar year next preceding
the calendar year in which such January 31 due date falls,less;
(B)The fair market value of that portion of the Company's Baytown
Plant annexed to the City of Baytown,which is 20%of the fair market
value within the City's jurisdictional area as of January 1 of the
calendar year next preceding the calendar year in which such January
31 due date falls,except for calendar years 1974 and 1975 as hereinafter
provided.
Annual payments under this Agreement shallbe calculated by the City
of Baytown in the above stated manner.Determination ofCity and Industrial
District fair market value in the above stated manner shall be made by City
of Baytown and approved by the Board of Equalization.Such final fair market
value as approved by the Board of Equalization shall be subject to exception
by the Company and should the Company take exception to the fair market value
of such property as determined by the Board and should the Board andthe Company
be unable,through negotiations,to reach a mutually acceptable fair market
-3-
r value on or before September 1 of the calendar year next preceding the calendar
year in which such January 31 due date falls,then either party may request
determination of such disagreement by a mutually acceptable arbitrator.The
cost of such arbitrator shall be shared equally by the City of Baytownand
the Company,and such arbitrator's determination shall be final and binding
unless either party within thirty (30)days after such arbitrator's determination
is received by the parties,petitions for a DeclaratoryJudgment to the Civil
District Courtof Harris County,Texas,as provided forby Section 5 hereof.
Should the parties be unable to agree upon a mutually acceptable arbi
trator,each party shall nominate one arbitrator and the arbitrators so nominated
a by the parties shall select a third arbitrator who will act withthem as a
three-member arbitration panel to decide the disagreement between the parties
by the concurrence of a majority of such panel.Such arbitrator or arbitration
panel shall determine whether the fair market value of such property is as
contended bythe Board of Equalization,by the Company,orsome intermediate
value.The cost of such arbitration panelshall be shared equally by the City
of Baytown and the Company,and such panel's determination shall be final and
binding unless either party within thirty (30)days after such determination
is received by the parties,petitions for a Declaratory Judgment to the Civil
District Court of Harris County,Texas,as provided for by Section 5 hereof.
In determining the fair market value of property and improvements
as used herein,the Board of Equalization and any arbitrator or arbitration
panel shall base its determination on the replacement cost of comparable present
day facilities considering and giving effect to sound engineering valuation
practices relative to service life,life expectancy,process and functional
obsolescence.
4.The Company and the City recognize the necessity of uniform appli
cation of Industrial District provisions.The Company and the City further
recognize that such uniform application will require some annexations and some
disannexations of industrial areas over the period 1974 to1976.Timing dif
ference in such annexations and disannexations could reduce assessed values
f*for the City for this period.In view of the need for maintaining current
levels of industrial assessed value during this period,the Company will render
-4-
One Million Fifty-Nine Thousand Three Hundred.
Five and No/100 ($1,059,305.00)Dollars
#^to the City in 1974 and 1975 a minimum value of for the portion of its Baytown
Plant annexed to the City.This value equates to the final 1973 assessed tax
value base as determined by the City's Board of Equalization.
The Company and the City agree that the Company's total annual payment
to the City for 1974 will be based onan ad valorem tax payment plus an Industrial
District payment.The total payment will consist of an ad valorem tax payment
on a minimum assessment of One Million Fifty-Nine Thousand Three Hundred Five and
No/100 ($1,059,305.00)Dollars plus an Industrial District payment sufficient
to bring the total payment to Nineteen Thousand Six Hundred Forty-Three and No/100
($19,643.00)Dollars.
rThe Company andthe City agree that the Company's total annual payment
to the City for the year 1975 will be based on theIndustrial District payment
formula as provided in Section 3,plus an ad valorem tax payment.The total
payment would consist of the ad valorem tax applicable to an assessed value
of One Million Fifty-Nine Thousand Three Hundred Five and No/100 ($1,059,305.00)
Dollars and a variable Industrial Districtpayment to be determined by substracting
the aforementioned ad valorem tax from a total amount calculated using an ad
valorem tax paymentbased on twenty (20%)percent of the market value of the
Company's Baytown Plant within the City's jurisdiction and an Industrial District
payment based on eighty (80%)percent of the market value of the plant within
the City's jurisdiction,as defined in Section 3.Such total payment shall
r not be less than the ad valorem tax applicable toan assessed value of One Million
Fifty-Nine Thousand Three Hundred Five and No/100 ($1,059,305.00)Dollars,even
tf the calculated payment using the Section 3 market value percentages is lower.
5.If any disagreement arises between the parties concerning the
interpretation of this Agreement or the decisions of the arbitrator or arbitration
panel provided for hereunder,it is agreed that either ofsaid parties may
petition any Civil District Courtof Harris County,Texas,for a Declaratory
Judgment detennining said controversy and the cause shallbe tried as other
civil causes in which plaintiff must establish by a preponderance of the evidence
the correct interpretation of valuation.Pending final determination of said
jbn controversy,the Company shall pay to the City on thedue date thesame amount
-5-
which it paid to the City forthe last preceding period as to which there was
no controversy concerning the amount owed by the Company to the City.The
Company agrees to tender the amount of potential liability to the registry
of the Civil District Court,Harris County,Texas,pending final determination
of the controversy beyond any further appeal.
6.All payments of the City of Baytown provided for herein shall
be made to the City at the City Hall in Baytown,Texas.If any payment is
not made on or before the due date,thesame penalties,interest,attorneys'
fees and costs of collection shall be recoverable by the City as would be collectible
In the case of delinquent ad valorem taxes;provided,however,that this sentence
shall not apply to any payment whichmay be found to have been deficient as
the result of proceedings provided for in Section 5 hereof.The City shall
have a lienupon any delinquency in Industrial District payment.
7.If any other municipality attempts to annex any land orproperty
owned,used,occupied,leased,rented or possessed by the Company within the
area designated as Baytown Industrial District No.1,more particularly described
in Appendix A to this agreement,or if the creation of any new municipality
.should be attempted so as to include within its limits any of such land or
property,the Cityof Baytown shall,with the cooperation of the Company,seek
injunctive relief against any such annexation or incorporation,and shall take
such other legal steps as may be necessary or advisable under the circumstances.
The cost of such legal steps,including fees of attorneys (other than the City
Attorney)retained by mutual agreement of the parties,shall be paidby the
Company.Shouldthe City refuse or fail to comply with its obligation under
this paragraph,the Company shall have the right to seek such legal or equitable
relief as it deems necessary or advisable in its own name or in the name of
the City and,if necessary,the Company may join the City as a party to any
such legal action.
If the City andthe Company are unsuccessful in preventing any such
attempted annexation or incorporation,the Company shall have the right to
terminate this Agreement as to any property so annexed or incorporated retroactive
-6-
to the effective dateof such annexation or incorporation,or the Company may
continue this Agreement in full force and effect;provided,however,thatthe
Company's right of terminating this Agreement must be exercised withinthirty
(30)days after judgment upholding such annexation or incorporation becomes
final beyond further appeal.If any payment is made by the Company to the
City after the effective date of such annexation or incorporation and if the
Company elects to terminate this Agreement as above provided,then as to such
property so annexed or incorporated such payment shall be refunded by the City
to the Company.
8.The City and the Company mutually recognize that the health and
welfareof Baytown residents require adherence to high stands of quality in
theair emissions,water effluents and noise,vibration and toxic levels of
thoseindustries located in the Baytown Industrial District No.1.To this
end,the Company andthe City agree that the same standards and criteria re
lative to noise,vibration and toxic levels which are adopted by the City and
applicable to portions of the City adjacent the Company's Baytown Plant shall
also be applicable to the plant within the Industrial District;provided however,
that said standards and criteria,if adopted,shall not operate to prohibit or
restrain anyactivities presently carried onby the Company within the Industrial
District and the City atpresent levels of operation and under presently existing
operating conditions.The Companyfurther agrees to abide by the rules and
regulations andthe permits issued toit by the Environmental Protection Agency,
the Texas Water Quality Board,the Texas Air Control Board,andany other governmental
agency having legal authority in these matters.In this connection,it is
recognized between the parties that these agencies are charged with the responsibility
for enforcing air and water quality standards,and it is agreed that so long
as the Environmental Protection Agency,the Texas Water Quality Board,the
Texas Air Control Board,and other related agencies are charged with such responsi
bility,nothing contained herein shall be construed to impose upon the City
of Baytown any responsibility,authority,orright,by termination of this
-7-
r Agreement or otherwise,to enforce any standards relative to air and water
quality as are "established by law,rule,regulation or permit.It is also
agreed that no violation of anystandards or criteria adopted by the City shall
be a reason for termination of this Agreement.
9.This Agreement shall be for a term of seven (7)years from the
date this instrument is executed and for such additional periodor periods
of time as provided by the Texas Municipal Annexation Act and mutually agreed
upon by the parties hereto.This Agreement shall further terminate and replace
that certain Industrial District agreement entered into between United Carbon
Company,Division of Ashland Oil &Refining Company andthe Cityof Baytown,
^dated September 28,1967.
10.The benefitsaccruing to the Company under this Agreement shall
also extend to the Company's "affiliates"and to any propertiesowned or acquired
by said affiliates within the area described in Appendix A to this Agreement,
and where reference is made herein to land,property and improvements owned
by the Company,that shall also include land,property and improvements owned
by its affiliates.The word "affiliates"as used herein shall mean all companies
withrespect to which the Company directly or indirectly,through one or more
intermediaries atthe time in question,owns or has the power to exercise the
control over fifty (50%)percent ormore of the stock having the right to vote
forthe election of directors.
11.It is agreed by the parties to this Agreement thatonly full,
complete and faithful performance of the terms hereof shall satisfy the rights
and obligations assumed by the parties and that,therefore,in addition to
any action at lawfor damages which either party may have,the Company may
enjoin the enactment or enforcement of any ordinance or charter amendment in
violation of,or in conflict with,the terms of this Agreement and may obtain
such other equitable relief,including specificperformance of the Agreement,
as is necessary to enforce its rights.It is further agreed that should this
Agreement be breached by the Company,the City shall be entitled,in addition
to anyaction at law for damages,to obtain specific performance of this Agreement
f^and such other equitable relief necessary to enforce its rights.However,
-8-
nothing contained herein shall be construed to give the City any right to terminate
this Agreement.on the basis of the Company's violation of any standard or criteria
relative to air emissions,water effluents,noise,vibration,or toxic levels
established by any law,ordinance,rule,regulation or permit.
12.In the event the terms and conditions of this contract are rendered
ineffective bythe Constitution and/or Legislative changes,both parties mutually
agree thatsaid contract shall be re-negotiated to accomplish the intentof
this agreement.
EXECUTED IN DUPLICATE ORIGINALS this day of ,
A.D.,1974.
ASHLAND CHEMICAL COMPANY,DIVISION
OF ASHLMD OIL,INC.
ATTEST:
Administrative Vice President
Deputy Secretary
ATTEST:
CITY OF BAYTOWN
TOM GENTRY,Mayor
By.
EDNA OLIVER,CityClerk
-9-
APPENDIXA
BEING a tract of land containing 36.798 acres,more or less,situated in the
William ScottUpper League,Abstract No.66,andthe William Hi 1 bus Survey,
4^Abstract No.336,Harris County,Texas,and being a portion of that certain
^52.274 acre tractof land conveyed to William B.White,Trustee,by H.D.
Jones,et al,by deed recorded in Volume 4248 at Page 80 of the Deed Records
of Harris County,Texas,and being more particularly described by metes and
bounds as follows:
BEGINNING at the Northwest cornerof the said William Scott Upper League,
also being the Southwest corner of the Harvey Whiting League,A-840;
THENCE,North S^lAMl"East along the common boundary line of the said
Harvey Whiting League and the said William Scott Upper League,a distance
of 576.10 feet to the West line of a Humble Pipeline Company8.194 acre
tract;
THENCE,South 0°45'East,with the West line of said Humble Pipeline
Company.8.194 acre tract,a distance of 1,563.98 feet toan anglepointinsaidVestTine;
THENCE,South 21°10'West,continuing with the West line of said Humble
Pipeline Company 8.194 acre tract,a distance of989.55 feet toan angle
**point in said West line;
THENCE,South 53°09'West,continuing with the West line ofsaid Humble
Pipeline Company 8.194 acre tract,a distance of165.13 feet to a point
in the most Southerly South lineof the above mentioned 52.274 acre
tract;
THENCE,North 88°59'West,with the most Southerly South line of the said
52.274 acre tract,a distance of 461.97 feet to the most Southerly South
west corner of said 52.274 acretract,said corner being located in the
East line of the James Strange Survey,A-71,and the West line of the
said William ScottUpper League;
THENCE,North 20°50'East,along the common boundary line of the said
James Strange Survey and the William Scott Upper League,a distance of
1,077.65 feet to the Northeast corner of the James Strange Survey and
the most Southerly Southeast corner of the said William Hi 1bus Survey;
THENCE,North 68°45'West along the common boundary line of the said
"James Strange Survey and the said William Hilbus Survey,a distance of
398.918 feet to a point,said pointbeinglocated South 68°45'East,f^a distance of 769.382 feet from the most Westerly Southwest corner of
said 52.274 acretract;
THENCE,North 22°19'East,a distance of 509.081 feet to a point located
in a boundary line of said 52.274 acre tract,said point being located
South 68°40'East,a distance of 769.361 feetfrom the mostWesterly
Northwest corner of the said 52.274 acre tract;
THENCE,South 68°40'East,a distance of 194.638 feet toan interior
corner of the said 52.274 acretract,said corner being situated in the
common boundary line of the said William Scott Upper League and the said
William Hilbus Survey;
THENCE,North l°09'West along the common boundary line of the said
William Scott Upper League and the said William Hilbus Survey,a distance
of 1,015.40 feet to the POINT OF BEGINNING,enclosing a tract of land
containing 36.798 acres,more or less.
gijj.ljj.